Plantagenet, and Tudor kings were arbitrary rulers, yet powerless to prevent innumerable acts of oppression, cruelty, and wrong, and had themselves small feeling for suffering. None but a highwayman would have stopped a coach in the last century, though it were likely to run over a woman or child. Now persons of high rank are ordered about by a policeman, and bidden to stop or go this way or that as he directs. When a fire takes place, the neighbouring houses may be injured or destroyed, and their inmates turned into the street, to prevent the conflagration from spreading. Men are compelled to vaccinate their children, to send them to school, to serve on juries themselves, and try prisoners, at great inconvenience and loss; and they would be forced to bear arms as soldiers in defence of the country were it invaded. The notions of some politicians about liberty are partly survivals of muddy eighteenth century theories of natural rights, and partly results of thoughtlessness respecting the nature and objects of civil government, and the numerous restraints it imposes which they never think of disputing. It is not on behalf of landlords and agents alone that preventive measures against outrage are needed in Ireland, but also of thousands of peaceable, industrious, and thrifty tenants and their families. At a public meeting a few weeks ago Mr. Parnell's secretary spoke with theatrical and grotesque commiseration of the anxiety an assassin, who had shot a man a few days before, must have endured while lying in wait for his victim. Think of the anguish of mind he must have suffered during those hours!' Good citizens are likely to think more of the anguish of mind in the homes of honest men who are liable to be fired at through their windows at night, dragged out of bed, carded, cruelly beaten, mutilated, and finally perhaps murdered, for paying their debts, or farming land that had never been decently farmed before. Principles adverse to that of the general good, Bentham has contemptuously characterised as maxims of sympathy and antipathy. 'Punish as you hate; if you hate not, punish not at all.' There are doubtless persons who, exasperated at the fiendish outrages committed in Ireland, are disposed to punish as they hate; yet the politicians who oppose the coercive measures necessary to prevent their commission, because their own anger and antipathy are not aroused in the cause of Irish landlords, may be more cold-blooded, but are not less irrational. Among the measures most urgently needed is a change in the Irish jury system. A country of which most of the inhabitants resembled Lord O'Hagan would have small need of any criminal jury system at all; but the noble lord overestimated the stage of advancement his own country had attained, and the Jury Act that goes by his name is an obstacle to its attainment.5 6 5 A resident magistrate of great ability and long experience says on this subject: 'No amelioration of affairs can be expected until crime is punished, and that cannot be as long as the present jury system exists. From the class from which petty jurors are taken emanate agrarian outrages, disaffection, and perjury. It is childish 6 Repression of agrarian crime is an indispensable step towards the solution of the Irish land question, but it is only a step. It will never be solved until so large a number of the Irish people are on the side of landed property that its rights are sacred in the eyes of the majority. Fixity of tenure, fair rents, and free sale,' would stop short of creating a multitude of families interested in the maintenance of landownership, and taking a pride and a pleasure in it. Acute logicians like Lord Sherbrooke will easily find objections to any plan of diffusing landownership by the intervention of the State. But logicians should remember Archbishop Whately's refutation of 'the fallacy of objections,' that is to say, of concluding that a system is untenable because some objections may be urged against it. The true question is whether there are not greater objections to its rejection. There may be risk in adopting it, but much greater danger in turning away from it for fear of them. The British Empire is surrounded with risks; so is every undertaking in life. There is risk in going out of one's house; but the slothful man who says, there is a lion without,' is more likely to perish by bringing the wolf to his door. T. E. C. LESLIE. to expect such a tribunal to punish the guilty. Nothing takes the heart out of all entrusted with the administration of the law so much as to see, assizes after assizes, juries retiring to "consider their verdict," and returning half an hour afterwards to affirm that in their belief the accused did not commit the offence with which he has been charged, though proved in the clearest manner.' NOTICE TO CORRESPONDENTS. Communications to the Editor should be addressed to him at 39 Paternoster Row, E.C. As the Magazine has an ample staff of Contributors, MSS. are not invited without previous correspondence, and uninvited MSS. cannot be returned ez 380] INDEX ΤΟ VOL. XXII. NEW SERIES. AFFAIR SIMPSON' (The), by H. J. M., rtist (An) on Art, by Harry Quilter, rtist (The): a Sonnet, 47 sia Minor, A Forgotten Empire in, by Autumn in the Côte-d'Or (An), by Miss Béranger: his Songs and Politics, by Blues and Buffs: a Sketch of a Con- Celtic College, an Early, by Hugh Mac- Characters, Overbury's, by James Pur- Copyright, Landowning and, by Grant Côte-d'Or, An Autumn in the, by Miss DAISY (One) and Two Violets, by Alex- Dax, by R. Herbert Story, D.D., 541 EARLY CELTIC COLLEGE (An), by Hugh Easy Methods, by T. E. Cliffe Leslie, Economical Reform at Oxford, by an Education and Boots, by 'The Riverside English Pauperism: its Wrong and English Rural Walk (An), by T. E FIRST RADICAL, The Romance of the: a Forgotten Hero (A), by Annie Walker, Frances Ridley Havergal, by P. Anton, GREEK HAMLET (A), 511 HAMLET (A Greek), 511 Hero, A Forgotten, by Annie Walker, Horses and their Feet, by Sir George Hospital Nursing, by H. C. Burdett, J12 House of Lords (The) and Popular Edu- cation, by An Old Educationalist, 261 Inverawe and Ticonderoga, by the Very Rev. the Dean of Westminster, 501 JOB, The Book of: a Literary and Bio- LAND QUESTION, The Irish, by T. E. Landowning and Copyright, by Grant Leaders (Political) and the Political London, the Water Supply of, by F. R. Love Match, An Historical, by Alex. C. Lux in Tenebris, by the late Lady Char- Lyric Poetry, Three Phases of, by Tho- MARY ANERLEY: a Yorkshire Tale, by XLVII. A Tangle of Veins, 80 XLIX. A Bold Angler, 234 L. Princely Treatment, 239 LV. Nicholas the Fish, 324 425 Morris (Lewis), The Poetry of, by Tho- NATIVES OF INDIA (The), by Lord Ninth Century, A Religious Poem of 112 OLDEST STATE IN EUROPE, A Visit to Overbury's Characters, by James Purves, PARLIAMENTARY DIFFICULTIES AND PO- Pauper Children in Scotland, The Up- Peace-at-any-Price Party (The), by Poetry (The) of Lewis Morris, by Tho- Political Leaders and the Political Fu- Political Parties, Parliamentary Diffi- Popular Education, The House of Lords Prison Visiting, by F. M. F. Skene, 752 RAILWAY SAFETY, The Problem of, by Rajah Yayati, The Penitence of, by Rumpty-Dudget, by Julian Hawthorne, 397 Sonnet, by Alexander Anderson, 527 THEEDA: an Allegory, by Julian Ha UP-BRINGING (The) of Pauper Chi in Scotland, by John Skelton, 21: by J. Theodore Bent, 808 |